CRO breakdown of My Insurance Finder's insurance lead gen page. Expert analysis of multi-step form strategy, trust hierarchy, and insurance-specific CRO by Apexure.
What is ConvertScore™? ConvertScore™ is Apexure's proprietary landing page performance metric. We evaluate every page across four dimensions — Copy & Messaging, Layout & Hierarchy, Trust & Social Proof, and CTA & Conversion Path — to produce a single score out of 100.
Insurance lead generation is one of the highest-friction categories in digital marketing. Visitors arrive sceptical — they’ve been through confusing plan comparisons, aggressive carrier sales teams, and bait-and-switch pricing. My Insurance Finder’s value proposition is being the independent guide that helps them navigate the complexity.
The page needed to communicate that independence and expertise immediately, while reducing the anxiety that typically prevents insurance leads from converting.
The bright yellow CTA palette creates immediate visual hierarchy against the white page. Yellow reads as approachable and optimistic — the opposite of the grey institutional aesthetic most insurance companies use. This colour choice signals consumer-first positioning at a glance.
The “Why Choose My Insurance Finders” section uses three columns: We Do The Heavy Lifting, Simple and Personalised, and Licensed Experts. This benefit framing directly addresses the three main fears of insurance shoppers: the process being complex (we do the work), the result being generic (it’s personalised), and the person advising them being unqualified (they’re licensed). Each column heading is an anxiety-resolver.
The “How It Works” process section — Step 1: Call, Step 2: Connect with Advisor, Step 3: Apply Directly — makes the process transparent before asking for commitment. For insurance, where many consumers fear being trapped in an endless sales process, showing the exit at step 3 (“apply directly”) removes the “will I be pestered forever?” objection.
The coverage chart showing “Insurance Plans for Everyone” with visual tiers is a sophisticated trust element. It communicates that the service covers a range of needs and budgets, not just premium-tier options. Consumers who feel they might not qualify for good coverage see that the service was designed with them in mind.
The FAQ section with accordion panels addresses the Healthcare Marketplace questions that are likely search terms: “What is the Healthcare Marketplace?”, “What is the Insurance Exchange?”. This SEO-aligned FAQ structure ensures the page ranks for the informational queries that precede the transactional query.
The most effective insurance landing pages don't sell insurance — they sell the advisor relationship. When the page's primary promise is "we'll help you navigate this confusing landscape," the visitor feels represented rather than sold to. That shift in perceived relationship is the conversion difference between a frustrated abandon and a confident form submission.
Insurance trust is built in layers. Regulatory credibility: “Licensed Experts” establishes that advisors are qualified and compliant. Process transparency: the three-step section shows the visitor exactly what will happen. Coverage data: the plan comparison chart shows real coverage options. FAQ resolution: the healthcare marketplace FAQ sections address the specific terminology that confuses consumers and causes them to leave.
"In insurance, trust isn't built by claiming 'we're trustworthy' — it's built by showing you understand the visitor's confusion and have a plan to resolve it. The three-step process section, the licensed experts badge, and the FAQ section aren't decorative. Each one is answering a specific anxiety that causes insurance leads to abandon the page."
Read more about how we approach trust signals in our guide to Landing Page Form Design Best Practices.
The Aetna Financial/Bright Health partner logo in the footer is a quiet trust signal. Insurance consumers may not know My Insurance Finder, but they know these carrier names. Seeing recognisable insurance brands in partnership implies that the service operates within a regulated, legitimate ecosystem — not a data-harvesting operation.
The page has two conversion mechanisms operating simultaneously: a phone number for high-intent visitors who want to talk now, and a lead form for research-phase visitors who want to go at their own pace. This dual-path approach captures both segments rather than forcing all traffic through a single bottleneck. The sticky header ensures the phone number is visible at every scroll depth.
"Dual-path conversion is particularly valuable in insurance because the population of visitors includes both decision-ready callers and research-phase browsers. A page with only a form loses the callers; a page with only a phone number loses the browsers. Offering both paths and letting the visitor self-select their readiness is the highest-yield strategy."
Unbounce was chosen for its flexibility with multi-path conversion flows. The sticky header, phone number placement, and form positioning were all configured without developer involvement, allowing rapid iteration on conversion rate.
Insurance searches are mobile-heavy, often triggered by a life event — a new job, a family change, an approaching open enrollment deadline. The phone number CTA becomes a tap-to-call on mobile, which is the fastest possible conversion path. We ensured the form fields were large enough for easy mobile completion.
Insurance pages attract high cost-per-click traffic. Every second of load time that causes a visitor to bounce wastes real budget. We kept the page clean and image-light, using CSS-styled UI elements rather than image-based graphics wherever possible to maintain sub-2-second load times.
Three changes would improve this page’s performance:
The dual-path conversion strategy and process transparency section are excellent for this category. The coverage chart and FAQ section show genuine attention to the consumer’s specific anxieties. The score reflects the opportunity for state-level personalisation and the addition of real-time availability signals that would convert the high-intent caller segment more effectively.
Browse our full collection of landing page examples to see how we apply these principles across industries. Need an insurance or financial services landing page? Talk to our team.
Controlling what visitors see first, second, and third guides them toward the conversion goal.
People follow the actions of others. Testimonials, reviews, and client logos build trust and reduce hesitation.
Simpler pages convert better. Reducing visual noise, breaking forms into steps, and clear copy lower mental effort.
Eye-tracking shows people scan pages in an F-shape. Placing key content along this path increases engagement.
My Insurance Finder is an insurance comparison and advisory service that connects consumers with licensed advisors across healthcare, life, home, and auto insurance categories. The service is designed for people who find the insurance marketplace confusing and want expert guidance without the pressure of dealing directly with a single carrier's sales team.
Insurance decisions benefit from human conversation — plans have complexity that's hard to resolve in a form. The primary 'Call' CTA captures high-intent visitors immediately while the form captures those who prefer to research at their own pace. For an advisory service, a phone call is both the fastest path to conversion and the highest-quality lead type, since it bypasses the follow-up delay of form submission.
Insurance is a category where consumers feel confused and potentially exploited. The three-step process section — Call, Connect with Advisor, Apply Directly — makes the service model transparent before asking for any commitment. When visitors understand how the process works, they're more willing to start it. Opacity breeds hesitation; clarity enables action.
Insurance is a data-driven purchase. Consumers want to see numbers: coverage amounts, premium ranges, plan comparisons. The bar chart showing 'Insurance Plans for Everyone' with coverage tiers communicates scope and accessibility in a format the target audience already understands. Data visualisations signal analytical competence and reduce the perception that the service is just a sales funnel.
We design high-converting landing pages for B2B and B2C brands. Let's talk about yours.
Get a Free Consultation Or browse more examples →
Founder & CEO of Apexure, Waseem worked in London's Financial Industry. He has worked on trading floors in BNP Paribas and Trafigura, developing complex business systems. Waseem loves working with Startups and combines data and design to create improved User Experiences.
Get quality posts covering insights into Conversion Rate Optimisation, Landing Pages and great design
"Insurance landing pages fail when they look like the carrier's website — because that's exactly what the visitor is trying to avoid. My Insurance Finder's page had to look and feel different: independent, advisory, and on the consumer's side. That meant warm colours, plain-language copy, and a process section that explained how the service works without making the visitor feel like they were being funnelled."